Butler’s Failure to Protect Children
Mark Butler backs puberty blockers for minors while the accompanying evidence review leaves fundamental questions unanswered.
Mark Butler backs puberty blockers for minors while the accompanying evidence review leaves fundamental questions unanswered.
Children should not be given puberty blockers to facilitate gender transition. A government serious about protecting children would draw that line clearly. Mark Butler has instead put the authority of his office behind advice allowing the practice to continue.
On 16 November, the Health Minister welcomed the National Health and Medical Research Council’s conditional recommendation that puberty suppressants remain an option for under-18s. The advice is open for consultation, with the full national guidelines due in late 2028. Children’s development, meanwhile, proceeds under recommendations whose evidentiary limitations deserve far more scrutiny than Butler’s reassuring language supplies.
Consider the eligibility criteria. The young person must have commenced puberty, have gender incongruence and be assessed as suitable by clinicians. The NHMRC explicitly includes gender incongruence “with or without distress”. Distress is therefore not even required before drugs that suppress normal pubertal development can be considered.
That is an extraordinary threshold. A child’s confusion about being a boy or a girl is no justification for medically interrupting normal development. Adults have a duty to protect the child’s future, including the future that child cannot yet imagine.
The accompanying evidence review exposes the gulf between institutional confidence and established knowledge. The research does not give clear answers about whether puberty blockers ease children’s distress about their sex, make them more comfortable with their bodies or improve their lives. The review found no eligible studies reporting deaths by suicide or examining fertility potential.
Those gaps concern the very outcomes families need to understand. Calling a recommendation evidence-based does not make the missing answers appear. Nor does placing several professionals around a consultation table settle questions that research has left unresolved.
Butler’s response to scrutiny was particularly revealing. Asked about differences from the Cass Review, he praised the NHMRC’s standing and said: “I’m not going to question the advice”.
Then who, Minister, is supposed to answer for the policy?
Respect for medical expertise does not require political submission. A minister’s responsibility includes asking whether the evidence justifies exposing children to an intervention, especially when the consequences reach beyond their present understanding. Supposed institutional prestige cannot discharge that responsibility.
The burden of proof belongs with those proposing to interrupt a child’s normal development. Children should never bear the consequences of adults lowering that burden because a treatment has acquired fashionable language and powerful institutional supporters.
Young people struggling with their bodies deserve patient, compassionate care: serious psychological support, protection from bullying and adults willing to listen without rushing towards medical intervention. Their vulnerability strengthens the obligation to protect them.
My position is straightforward: Australia should prohibit puberty blockers for gender transition in minors. Childhood must remain a protected period in which young people can mature without having their normal development medically suppressed.
Butler had an opportunity to put that protection first. Instead, he offered deference where leadership was required.
Children need adults with the courage to say no.
“Open thy mouth for the dumb in the cause of all such as are appointed to destruction.”
– Proverbs 31:8, King James Version.
Join 50K+ readers of the no spin Weekly Dose of Common Sense email. It's FREE and published every Wednesday since 2009